Nonduality: The Varieties of Expression Home

Jerry Katz
photography & writings

The wind carves shapes into the beach sand

Search over 5000 pages on Nonduality:

Click here to go to the next issue

Highlights Home Page | Receive the Nonduality Highlights each day

How to submit material to the Highlights

#3546 - Thursday, May 28, 2009 - Editor: Jerry Katz

The Nonduality Highlights -    

I appreciate the writings and teachings of Dr. Stewart Bitkoff. They're eminently practical and grounded in Sufism. Here is a longish and easy to read article by Stewart.  

"Often for many events in life, we cannot control harmful outcomes; when something painful or chaotic occurs, we must feel and honor the pain.  Yet, experience teaches with a little hard work we can limit fear and worry about potentials; all of us must learn to separate out what is a possibility, and learn to use the tools in our personal tool box to move past potentials and reach happier, more tranquil states."  -SB    


How to be Spiritual Amidst this Chaos?

                          By Dr. Stewart Bitkoff



Circumstances have overtaken man. His old languages are not sufficient to describe what is happening, and what is about to happen. To think in terms of a millennium or such tame concepts as ‘the eleventh hour’ is ridiculous. Better that he should realize that he is in an era which might be more accurately described as the ‘eighth day of the week.”  Idries Shah


                                               *     *     *


            For the spiritual traveler, we are living in a complex and unique age; one of tremendous upheaval and great opportunity to solve problems. Turn on the television set and listen to the reports coming in from all across the world: religious wars, effects of global warming, famine, new strains of disease, drug wars, over weight children, advances in technology and people beginning to work together to solve problems of housing, job loss, and keeping their family together.  This combination of factors has been called the ‘eighth day of the week’ and the beginning of a new era; clearly, until many of these problems are resolved, if that is possible, the amount of unsettledness, fear, anxiety and personal worry for many will continue to grow. 


For increasing numbers of people, the personal balancing factor to this stress and chaos, is spiritual development. It must be added to the mix and used with our other capacities to find solutions. Higher knowledge will not replace common sense, experience, hard work, or economic imperative.  That is not its function.  It is an added capacity which integrates and works alongside others.


The present discussion will examine some basic thoughts about being spiritual; and how spiritual capacity can help the traveler deal with this period of chaos and change.


                        What Does It Mean To Be Spiritual?


  What does the term spiritual mean?  Spiritual is not an easy word to define, because there is an experiential aspect to it, with many levels and dimensions.  Sort of like love, which is a sublime experience and occurs in many forms; poets and song writers proclaim its virtues and sorrows, yet, no matter how fine the words, they are only an approximation.


Typical definitions include phrases such as: spiritual means of the spirit. This type of definition defines itself using the same word, yet, surprisingly is reasonably accurate. Spiritual does mean of the spirit.


For the spiritual traveler, the soul is comprised of a spiritual energy fabric; this spiritual energy fabric is the source of life and powers our body, 5 senses, emotions and consciousness.  To the soul, there is a higher and lower aspect which corresponds to different parts of our functioning (physical, mental, emotional, and spiritual); to further complicate, in some discussions soul/spirit are used interchangeably.



Characteristics of a Spiritual Person


Another way to help define spiritual is to examine personality traits of spiritual people.  These characteristics help us get a better understanding of what it means to be spiritual in daily life, however, there are problems here as well; while these traits are accurate, also, they can be said to exist in non-spiritual people:



While the spiritual traveler acknowledges problems in definition and realizes they are seeking an illusive essence, there is another part of the consciousness that offers: ‘do not worry- you will know it, when you find it.’  Like love- spiritual defines itself and by adding this capacity to your life, you life will be fuller, more complete and you will be better able to face life’s ups and downs.


Routine Change or the End?


Through increased information that is available via television and the internet, the average person viewing the unrest in our world cannot help but wonder: what is going on? Conversely, scientists and philosophers tell us, chaos and order are simply opposite ends of a continuum. Both are natural to life and necessary to the physical order. And so the spiritual traveler wonders: is this era simply a routine period of unrest- soon to be followed by a period of relative calm? 


Consider the following themes and ideas, and how each contributes to our fear and growing anxiety level.  Each of which can be found either in your religious/spiritual belief system or on your local television programs, nightly and weekly.


        Many religious/spiritual paths discuss a destruction/ending of sorts- of which many scenarios seem to coincide with this time period. Is this the end of the world?  Also, current scientifically based television shows describe ‘end of world’ natural disasters, questioning: will the world shift on its access?  Will a large meteor hit the earth?  Through global warming, will we send the earth into another ice-age?  When will the next super volcano erupt? Often these shows include prophetic references: are these events the earth changes that Cayce and other prophets have described?

        Some belief systems hold that previously there have been 4 destructions of the earth. The Mayan Calendar ends in year 2012; according to Sufi Tradition, the Stream of Life has died-up and will be replaced with the new Stream of Life.  Destruction and rebirth- natural cycles that have occurred many times?

        Recently, across the world, there has been a failure of government and large corporations to solve economic problems and timely react to natural disasters; also, for the average person, these institutions appear to have been at the center of many of the ills that affect us.  As a result, gradually, many are turning away from reliance upon authoritarian based models to individual based structures.  Slowly, we are collectively realizing that governments/corporations/religion alone cannot save us; we must all work to make the world better and begin this effort with ourselves. 

        More people are solving problems locally and gradually realizing that the world is made better one person at a time; this is the person centered approach.  Additionally, there is growing interest in spiritual paths that emphasize personal development.  Better individuals make a better world.

        Personal, Corporate, and Governmental Greed, along with Religious Fanaticism increasingly are threats to our way of life.

        Honoring the Earth Mother or destruction of the environment; how will it end?  Will we pull together or destroy the planet?

        Information explosion: boon or curse?  How ‘others’ manipulate us.



Understanding Emotion: Love and Fear


By nature, we are emotional and our reactions to life, through multiple feelings contribute to a richer, full experience. When something happens in daily life that is painful we all have a reaction to it.  We are multi-level beings and our emotions bring us both great joy and sadness. That is the way we are hardwired and for good health, must honor our feelings.


One model, suggests that all emotions arise from the 2 basic feelings of love and fear.  According to Frank Sant’Agata, all emotions can be traced back to these primary feelings.


“Love and fear are the only emotions we as human entities are able to express.  All the others are just sub-categorical emotions.  For example, on love’s side there is joy, peacefulness, happiness, forgiveness, and a host of others.  On the other hand, fear reflects: hate, depression, guilt, inadequacy, discontentment, prejudice, anger, attack, and so on.


Love and fear can not coexist. Where one is, the other can’t be also.  The one will leave immediately, should the other enter its presence.  If you find yourself in a situation where you are experiencing great joy, and are suddenly overtaken by fear, the joy is gone! But it works the other way too: If you are terrorized, frightened, or otherwise threatened in any way, all you need to do is turn to the love within and the fears disappears.”


Next time you are watching TV Talk Shows and the Host is trying to convince you of something, evaluate their presentation using the following criteria: is this a manipulation of the fear and reward stick.  Do as I say- good things will happen; if not, bad things will happen.  Most often, the media, politicians, some forms of religion, and corporations continually use this manipulation.  Unless you see the manipulation- it is very difficult to understand and disarm, particularly, when you are up against a formidable societal power structure.


From a spiritual standpoint, we want to become masters of our emotions, so we can temporarily get beyond them.  When we are emotionally charged, most often, the quiet, spiritual part of ourselves will not come forward.  It will not operate under these conditions


Daily Practices to Counter Fear


OK, so now that you have me totally paranoid, and frightened about the end of the world, what am I supposed to do about all of this?  Here are a few suggestions, from my personal tool box on life, to help you conquer your fear reaction, and more easily access that quiet part of yourself which is more peaceful and serene.                                   




And the more we practice controlling our consciousness and awareness, and seeing the fear/reward manipulation about us, the easier it will become to think more tranquil thoughts.  Then, one day we will experience what lies beyond emotions; and the higher consciousness will emerge.


Often for many events in life, we cannot control harmful outcomes; when something painful or chaotic occurs, we must feel and honor the pain.  Yet, experience teaches with a little hard work, we can limit fear and worry about potentials; all of us must learn to separate out what is a possibility, and learn to use the tools in our personal tool box to move past potentials and reach happier, more tranquil states. 


In 1969, it was during a BBC interview that Mrs. Beryl Worth, when questioned about her positive personal adjustment, to a recent potentially fatal diagnosis of cancer, answered in the following way.


‘I think it was St. Ignatius who was sweeping the corridor and his novices came and said to him, ‘If the world, if you knew the world were going to come to an end in 10 minutes, what would you do?  And he said, ‘Go on sweeping the corridor.” And that is just what I’m going to do.”


In every moment, life is ending and beginning; life is joy and pain, chaos and peace.  With every moment, after we have experienced what we need to experience; we must learn and remember to go on doing our work, and ‘continue sweeping the corridor.’


                                                *          *          *




Idries Shah, Knowing How To Know, The Octagon Press, London, 1998, p. 152.


This quote appears online at Frank Sant’Agata, On Love and Fear,, and accessed 3/22/09.


Interview with Mrs. Beryl Worth shortly before her death. BBC transcript “I’ll go on sweeping the corridor’ June 1969. Appearing in and compiled by: Cecil, Rieu, and Wade,

The King’s Son, The Octagon Press: The Institute for Cultural Research, 1981, p. 162.


                                                *          *          *


Also by Dr. Bitkoff, A Commuter’s Guide to Enlightenment, (Llewellyn, 2008) and Journey of Light: Trilogy, (Authorhouse, 2004); these books are available on or from publisher.  To contact author go to  

top of page